Nastro trasportatore di curriculum attraversato da un varco di scansione: quasi tutti i fogli cadono nel cestino, uno solo viene trattenuto da una mano umana

Immagine creata con IAAI-generated image

Automated candidate screening: the gap in Italy’s Legislative Decree 179/2026 is what European regulators will check in 2027

On 23 October 2026 Italy’s Legislative Decree No 179 of 7 October 2026 entered into force. Its Article 41 reserves to a natural person the final decisions on the employment relationship taken with the help of systems based on artificial intelligence - AI, but leaves the search for and selection of candidates outside that safeguard. Less than three weeks later, the European Data Protection Board - EDPB announced its 2027 coordinated enforcement action (EDPB press release of 11 November 2026). The action will cover precisely automated decision-making, including AI-driven decision-making, in recruitment. The phase that the Italian rule excludes from the prohibition is the same one on which data protection authorities will measure organisations’ practices.

Article 41 of Legislative Decree No 179/2026 and the exclusion of candidate search and selection

Article 41(1) requires employers that use AI systems to ensure that final decisions on the establishment, modification or termination of the employment relationship, including disciplinary measures and performance evaluations, are not taken solely on the basis of automated processing. The same provision states that the search for and selection of candidates are not such final decisions, even where they result in a candidate not being admitted to the later stages of the selection. The right to an intelligible explanation obtained through the intervention of a natural person, provided for in paragraph 3, belongs to the worker. The nullity in paragraph 4 applies to decisions taken in breach of paragraph 1 (text of the Decree, Gazzetta Ufficiale No 234 of 8 October 2026). We have already examined the consequences of this choice for gender bias in automated pre-selection. We have also analysed the Decree’s overall framework of authorities, penalties and employment decisions.

Paragraph 1, however, opens with a clause leaving Article 22 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 unaffected. The pre-selection excluded by the Decree therefore remains subject to the General Data Protection Regulation - GDPR. That is the ground on which the European action will take place.

The EDPB’s 2027 coordinated enforcement action on candidate screening tools

The 2027 coordinated action is part of the Coordinated Enforcement Framework - CEF. This is the mechanism through which national supervisory authorities examine, in parallel and with a common methodology, the same aspect of GDPR compliance. The actions concluded so far covered cloud services in the public sector, data protection officers, the right of access and the right to erasure (CEF page). The 2027 action will focus on the right not to be subject to decisions based solely on automated processing, and the related right of access. Its scope covers the use of automated candidate screening tools, including AI-driven ones. Authorities will join on a voluntary basis in the coming weeks, and the action will be launched during 2027.

The benchmarks are two provisions of the GDPR. Article 22 grants the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing which produces legal effects or similarly significantly affects the person. Recital 71 mentions e-recruiting practices without any human intervention among its examples. Article 15(1)(h) requires those exercising the right of access to be given ‘meaningful information about the logic involved’. The Court of Justice has read both provisions broadly. In SCHUFA Holding (C-634/21) of 7 December 2023 it treated the automated establishment of a probability value as automated individual decision-making where a third party to which it is transmitted draws strongly on it. In Dun & Bradstreet Austria (C-203/22) of 27 February 2025 it required that the data subject be told ‘the procedure and principles actually applied’. In our view, a score on which access to the interview depends may fall within this reasoning even where, formally, a person chooses among the finalists. The closest precedent examined on this site is the case of the automated deactivations of Uber drivers, built around Article 22.

AI Act obligations for recruitment systems from 2 December 2027

Annex III, point 4(a), of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 on artificial intelligence - AI Act classifies as high-risk the systems intended to be used for the recruitment or selection of natural persons. These include in particular systems used to place targeted job advertisements, to analyse and filter job applications and to evaluate candidates. Regulation (EU) 2026/1744, the so-called ‘Digital Omnibus on AI’, moved the application of the related obligations to 2 December 2027. The prohibitions in Article 5, by contrast, already apply, including the ban on emotion recognition systems in the workplace, in force since 2 February 2025. For almost the whole duration of the coordinated action, therefore, scrutiny of screening tools will run through the GDPR.

GDPR requirements for organisations using automated pre-selection

The first step is to map the tools that filter, rank or reject applications. These include tools built into applicant tracking platforms and those used by agencies and external providers on the organisation’s behalf. For each tool, it must be established whether any exclusion occurs without a person actually examining the application. That is where Article 22 applies, and human review must be effective, not a formal confirmation of the system’s output.

Where the decision is fully automated, one of the grounds in Article 22(2) is needed: necessity for entering into the contract, authorisation by Union or Member State law, or explicit consent. In the cases of contractual necessity and consent, Article 22(3) requires at least the right to obtain human intervention, to express one’s point of view and to contest the decision. The channel for exercising these rights should be in place before the selection starts. The privacy notice given to candidates must disclose the existence of automated decision-making and provide meaningful information about the logic involved, as required by Articles 13(2)(f) and 14(2)(g).

As regards the right of access, the organisation must be able to explain to a rejected candidate the procedure and principles applied to their application. This presupposes that the system provider makes that information available, a point to be governed in the processor contract under Article 28. Finally, a data protection impact assessment is mandatory under Article 35(3)(a) where a systematic and extensive evaluation of personal aspects based on automated processing underpins decisions with legal or similarly significant effects. In our view, this condition is frequently met by screening tools.

Conclusions

Legislative Decree No 179/2026 excluded the search for and selection of candidates from the safeguard in Article 41, but left Article 22 GDPR unaffected. For automated pre-selection, until 2 December 2027 the reference point therefore remains Article 22. It is against that provision that the authorities taking part in the coordinated action will compare organisations’ recruitment practices in 2027. Will coordinated scrutiny under Article 22 and, from 2 December 2027, the AI Act obligations be enough to fill the gap left by Article 41, or will the Italian legislature need to revisit this exclusion?


AI AnthropoCosmic In evidenzaAI AnthropoCosmicUn progetto internazionale per un’IA a servizio dell’Uomo, dell’Ambiente e del Cosmo, che mette al centro la dignità della persona nella progettazione dei sistemi. Leggi l’articoloAI Open Mind AI AnthropoCosmic FeaturedAI AnthropoCosmicAn international project for an AI at the service of humanity, the environment and the cosmos, placing human dignity at the centre of system design. Read the articleAI Open Mind Agentic AI In evidenzaAgentic AILimiti prima dell’azione, evidenze durante, responsabilità dopo. Il volume di Nicola Fabiano sulla governance dei sistemi agentici, con la prefazione di Antonino Caffo.Capitolo 16 a cura dell’Avv. Valentina Grazia SapuppoLeggi l’articolo Agentic AI FeaturedAgentic AILimits before the action, evidence during, responsibility afterwards. Nicola Fabiano’s book on the governance of agentic systems, with a preface by Antonino Caffo.Chapter 16 by Valentina Grazia SapuppoRead the article
Testimonianza di Valentina Grazia Sapuppo per XUKRA, Meeting Standards 2026 TestimonianzaXUKRA” · Meeting StandardsValentina Grazia Sapuppo ha portato la sua testimonianza al workshop online di XUKRA” nell’ambito di Meeting Standards, l’iniziativa di Small Business Standards che avvicina le PMI europee alla normazione.30 giugno 2026, online · Meeting Standards, 4ª edizioneXUKRA”Meeting StandardsIniziativa europea di Small Business Standards - SBS
Locandina del workshop DTRIP4H Exploring User Needs, 26 marzo 2026PanelDTRIP4H · Gemelli digitali per la saluteValentina Grazia Sapuppo tra i main panellist del workshop «Exploring User Needs for DDTE: Ethics, Implementation, and the Future of Responsible Simulation» del progetto europeo DTRIP4H, con un intervento su governance, conformità e responsabilità. A giugno ha contribuito come esperto legale al workshop sui fabbisogni formativi.26 marzo e 23 giugno 2026, online · Horizon EuropeIl workshopLa registrazioneDTRIP4H
Intervista Radio Radio IntervistaLegge e colossi del digitaleIl patteggiamento di Meta sui minori non è una condanna. Stati Uniti ed Europa seguono strade opposte, e sugli agenti di IA resta aperta la domanda su chi risponde.Un Giorno Speciale su Radio Radio, con Alessio De Paolis · audio dal minuto 2:26:00Ascolta l’intervistaGuarda il videoLeggi l’articolo
Digital Omnibus ContributoIl Digital Omnibus cambia l’AI ActNuove scadenze per i sistemi ad alto rischio e un chiarimento sull’obbligo di AI literacy: più tempo per adeguarsi, nessuno sconto sulla preparazione di persone e processi.Articolo scritto per il blog di SkillaLeggi su Skilla
Digeat Festival 2026 SpeakerDigeat Festival 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo tra i relatori del festival dedicato a protezione dei dati, archivi digitali e regole del futuro. Interviene sul tema «Le regole dell’IA: nuove leggi o principi del diritto?».Venerdì 6 novembre 2026, ore 16:30, Ex Convitto Palmieri, LecceL’interventoLa scheda relatriceIl festival
AI AnthropoCosmic 2026AI AnthropoCosmic 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo nel progetto dell’Università Pontificia Salesiana su Persona, Ambiente e Cosmo: moderazione della sessione mattutina del Convegno finale e intervento negli AI Laboratori del Domani su commercio elettronico e IA.14 novembre 2026, online · 28 novembre 2026, Università Pontificia Salesiana, RomaIl convegnoL’incontroIl contributoIl comitato scientificoLa relatriceIl progetto
Testimony by Valentina Grazia Sapuppo for XUKRA, Meeting Standards 2026 TestimonyXUKRA” · Meeting StandardsValentina Grazia Sapuppo’s testimony for the XUKRA” online workshop, part of Meeting Standards, the Small Business Standards initiative bringing European SMEs closer to standardisation.30 June 2026, online · Meeting Standards, 4th editionXUKRA”Meeting StandardsEuropean initiative by Small Business Standards - SBS
Poster of the DTRIP4H workshop Exploring User Needs, 26 March 2026PanelDTRIP4H · Digital twins for healthValentina Grazia Sapuppo among the main panellists of the workshop “Exploring User Needs for DDTE: Ethics, Implementation, and the Future of Responsible Simulation” of the EU project DTRIP4H, speaking on governance, compliance and accountability. In June she contributed as a legal expert to the workshop on training needs.26 March and 23 June 2026, online · Horizon EuropeThe workshopThe recordingDTRIP4H
Interview Radio Radio InterviewLaw and the digital giantsThe Meta settlement on minors is not a conviction. The United States and Europe take opposite paths, and on AI agents the question of who answers remains open.Un Giorno Speciale on Radio Radio, with Alessio De Paolis · audio from 2:26:00 · in ItalianListen to the interviewWatch the videoRead the article
Digital Omnibus ContributionThe Digital Omnibus reshapes the AI ActNew deadlines for high-risk systems and a clarification on the AI literacy duty: more time to comply, no discount on preparing people and processes.Article written for the Skilla blog, in ItalianRead on Skilla
Digeat Festival 2026 SpeakerDigeat Festival 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo among the speakers of the festival on data protection, digital archives and the rules of the future. She takes part in the panel «The rules of AI: new laws or principles of law?».Friday 6 November 2026, 16:30, Ex Convitto Palmieri, LecceThe panelSpeaker profileThe festival
AI AnthropoCosmic 2026AI AnthropoCosmic 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo in the project of the Università Pontificia Salesiana on Person, Environment and Cosmos: moderator of the morning session of the closing conference and speaker at the AI Laboratori del Domani on e-commerce and AI.14 November 2026, online · 28 November 2026, Università Pontificia Salesiana, Rome · sessions held in ItalianThe conferenceThe sessionThe contributionThe scientific committeeSpeakerThe project