Immagine di copertina: Lo smartphone come sfera privata: il Garante sanziona Meta per 805 milioni per l'accesso alla galleria di Facebook

Immagine creata con IAAI-generated image

The smartphone as a private sphere: the Garante fines Meta EUR 805 million over Facebook camera roll access

By decision No 815 of 13 November 2026, announced on 14 November, the Italian data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited EUR 805 million. Through the Facebook app for Android, the company accessed photos, videos and related metadata stored on Italian users’ smartphones without specific consent and without adequate information. The decision rests on Article 122 of Legislative Decree No 196 of 30 June 2003, Personal Data Protection Code - Italian Privacy Code, and not on Regulation (EU) 2016/679, General Data Protection Regulation - GDPR. Article 122 transposes Directive 2002/58/EC on privacy and electronic communications - ePrivacy Directive. That is the decision’s most significant feature. It allowed the Italian authority to act alone against a company established in Ireland, at the very time when the Digital Omnibus negotiations are addressing where the rules on access to devices should sit.

The feature and the findings

The decision, set out in the Garante press release, concerns the ‘Get camera roll suggestions when you’re browsing Facebook’ feature, available since 2023. While users browse, the feature shows them photos and videos from their phone’s camera roll as suggestions to post. The investigation was opened in July 2025 following a complaint by the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti of Bolzano and drew on a technical analysis carried out by the authority.

The investigation found three elements. First, access to the camera roll is requested through a single permission, valid for the whole app and for several functions with different needs. Second, the permission is preceded by a generic notice, ‘enable other features’, which does not let users understand that they are also authorising camera roll suggestions. Third, the feature was switched on by default. If granted in full, a permission of this kind allows the app to read the entire photo archive on the device, as a rule permanently. Neither the user nor the authority can verify which information is actually used.

The smartphone as a private sphere: Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code

The provision infringed is Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which transposes Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive. The Garante recalled its rationale: the smartphone is part of the individual’s private sphere, and any access to the information it holds requires free and informed consent, even where no harm occurs. In the decision, the Garante states that the provision is not a rule on the processing of personal data in the strict sense, but one that safeguards the integrity of the user’s private sphere. The protection therefore applies at an earlier stage: it does not depend on whether the information is personal or on whether it leaves the device.

The defect found is above all one of granularity. A single system permission, covering functions with different purposes and following a generic notice, is not the specific consent the provision requires. The Guidelines 05/2020 on consent of the European Data Protection Board - EDPB provide that, where processing pursues several purposes, consent should be obtained separately for each. On transparency, the case echoes a theme this blog has addressed on comprehensibility as a condition of transparency. Information that is present, but does not make clear what is being authorised, does not produce informed consent.

Why the Garante, and not the Irish authority, decided

Meta had argued that jurisdiction lay with the Irish authority. The objection was rejected because the ePrivacy rules do not provide for the one-stop-shop mechanism that the GDPR applies to cross-border processing. In this field each competent national authority applies its own transposing law. The Garante’s exclusive competence, however, covers only the stage of access to the terminal equipment. Referring to EDPB Opinion 5/2019 and to the judgment of the Court of Justice of 15 June 2021 in Case C-645/19, the decision points out that processing operations before and after that access remain subject to the GDPR and therefore to the one-stop-shop. The Garante will also send the decision to the Irish authority. The situation differs from the one examined in the VRT case and cookie banners, which concerned the right to lodge a complaint and the GDPR one-stop-shop.

The point is topical. The Digital Omnibus proposal presented by the European Commission on 19 November 2025, COM(2025) 837 final, would move the rules on access to personal data stored in terminal equipment into the GDPR, through a new Article 88a. In their Joint Opinion 2/2026 of 10 February 2026, the EDPB and the European Data Protection Supervisor - EDPS generally welcomed the allocation of supervision to the GDPR supervisory authorities, with the cooperation and consistency mechanism applying. In our view, for a controller with its main establishment in Ireland, this would as a rule make the Irish authority the lead supervisory authority under Article 56 GDPR. In the same opinion the two bodies warned that the protection of terminal equipment would be split between two regimes depending on whether the information is personal or non-personal. This concern adds to their doubts on the new definition of personal data.

The negotiating mandate agreed by the Council on 21 October 2026 follows a different approach. The rules on cookies remain in the ePrivacy Directive and are updated with additional purposes for which consent will not be required. Negotiations with the European Parliament will begin once Parliament has adopted its own position. In our view, if this approach were confirmed in the negotiations with the European Parliament, the allocation of competences that enabled the Garante’s decision would also remain in place.

The measures ordered and the amount of the fine

Within 60 days Meta must request consent through a separate and specific request for the feature. The request must explain to users what the feature is for, that it involves access to the camera roll and how to disable it. The feature must remain switched off by default, including for users who have already granted the permission. If the deadline passes without compliance, the feature may not be activated for users who have not given valid consent. The company must inform the Garante within 30 days of the steps taken and within 90 days of the measures adopted.

In setting the amount, the Garante first took into account the number of people affected, around 20 million Android users in Italy. It then considered the duration of the infringement, still ongoing for those who have not updated the app and for those who have already granted the system permission. Lastly, it took into account a previous 2019 decision against the company and the limited cooperation during the investigation. It treated as mitigating the changes introduced after the complaint, while finding them late and limited to users who update the app. The fine amounts to about 0.47% of the group’s worldwide turnover.

What the decision does not cover

The proceedings did not concern any use of camera roll content to train artificial intelligence systems, which Meta denies. The Garante has reserved the right to assess separately the new feature, launched in 2026, that allows camera roll content to be processed in the cloud.

For those who develop or distribute apps, the decision offers concrete guidance. A permission granted to the operating system does not replace the consent required by Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code. A feature that reads the content of the device for a purpose of its own requires a separate consent request, preceded by specific information, and a default setting that is switched off, unless access is strictly necessary for a service explicitly requested by the user. To publish individual photos, the technical report referred to in the decision points to Android’s system photo picker, which gives access only to the content selected, without system permissions. Supervision of access to terminal equipment remains with the national authorities, while subsequent processing remains within the scope of the GDPR.

Conclusions

The decision confirms that Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code protects terminal equipment as such, and that a generic operating system permission is not equivalent to specific consent. It also confirms that, as regards access to devices, the national authority can act directly against a controller established in another Member State. Will this allocation of competences survive the Digital Omnibus negotiations, or will the protection of terminal equipment end up depending on the lead authority of the place of establishment?

Author: Valentina Grazia Sapuppo


AI AnthropoCosmic In evidenzaAI AnthropoCosmicUn progetto internazionale per un’IA a servizio dell’Uomo, dell’Ambiente e del Cosmo, che mette al centro la dignità della persona nella progettazione dei sistemi. Leggi l’articoloAI Open Mind AI AnthropoCosmic FeaturedAI AnthropoCosmicAn international project for an AI at the service of humanity, the environment and the cosmos, placing human dignity at the centre of system design. Read the articleAI Open Mind Agentic AI In evidenzaAgentic AILimiti prima dell’azione, evidenze durante, responsabilità dopo. Il volume di Nicola Fabiano sulla governance dei sistemi agentici, con la prefazione di Antonino Caffo.Capitolo 16 a cura dell’Avv. Valentina Grazia SapuppoLeggi l’articolo Agentic AI FeaturedAgentic AILimits before the action, evidence during, responsibility afterwards. Nicola Fabiano’s book on the governance of agentic systems, with a preface by Antonino Caffo.Chapter 16 by Valentina Grazia SapuppoRead the article
Testimonianza di Valentina Grazia Sapuppo per XUKRA, Meeting Standards 2026 TestimonianzaXUKRA” · Meeting StandardsValentina Grazia Sapuppo ha portato la sua testimonianza al workshop online di XUKRA” nell’ambito di Meeting Standards, l’iniziativa di Small Business Standards che avvicina le PMI europee alla normazione.30 giugno 2026, online · Meeting Standards, 4ª edizioneXUKRA”Meeting StandardsIniziativa europea di Small Business Standards - SBS
Locandina del workshop DTRIP4H Exploring User Needs, 26 marzo 2026PanelDTRIP4H · Gemelli digitali per la saluteValentina Grazia Sapuppo tra i main panellist del workshop «Exploring User Needs for DDTE: Ethics, Implementation, and the Future of Responsible Simulation» del progetto europeo DTRIP4H, con un intervento su governance, conformità e responsabilità. A giugno ha contribuito come esperto legale al workshop sui fabbisogni formativi.26 marzo e 23 giugno 2026, online · Horizon EuropeIl workshopLa registrazioneDTRIP4H
Intervista Radio Radio IntervistaLegge e colossi del digitaleIl patteggiamento di Meta sui minori non è una condanna. Stati Uniti ed Europa seguono strade opposte, e sugli agenti di IA resta aperta la domanda su chi risponde.Un Giorno Speciale su Radio Radio, con Alessio De Paolis · audio dal minuto 2:26:00Ascolta l’intervistaGuarda il videoLeggi l’articolo
Digital Omnibus ContributoIl Digital Omnibus cambia l’AI ActNuove scadenze per i sistemi ad alto rischio e un chiarimento sull’obbligo di AI literacy: più tempo per adeguarsi, nessuno sconto sulla preparazione di persone e processi.Articolo scritto per il blog di SkillaLeggi su Skilla
Digeat Festival 2026 SpeakerDigeat Festival 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo tra i relatori del festival dedicato a protezione dei dati, archivi digitali e regole del futuro. Interviene sul tema «Le regole dell’IA: nuove leggi o principi del diritto?».Venerdì 6 novembre 2026, ore 16:30, Ex Convitto Palmieri, LecceL’interventoLa scheda relatriceIl festival
AI AnthropoCosmic 2026AI AnthropoCosmic 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo nel progetto dell’Università Pontificia Salesiana su Persona, Ambiente e Cosmo: moderazione della sessione mattutina del Convegno finale e intervento negli AI Laboratori del Domani su commercio elettronico e IA.14 novembre 2026, online · 28 novembre 2026, Università Pontificia Salesiana, RomaIl convegnoL’incontroIl contributoIl comitato scientificoLa relatriceIl progetto
Testimony by Valentina Grazia Sapuppo for XUKRA, Meeting Standards 2026 TestimonyXUKRA” · Meeting StandardsValentina Grazia Sapuppo’s testimony for the XUKRA” online workshop, part of Meeting Standards, the Small Business Standards initiative bringing European SMEs closer to standardisation.30 June 2026, online · Meeting Standards, 4th editionXUKRA”Meeting StandardsEuropean initiative by Small Business Standards - SBS
Poster of the DTRIP4H workshop Exploring User Needs, 26 March 2026PanelDTRIP4H · Digital twins for healthValentina Grazia Sapuppo among the main panellists of the workshop “Exploring User Needs for DDTE: Ethics, Implementation, and the Future of Responsible Simulation” of the EU project DTRIP4H, speaking on governance, compliance and accountability. In June she contributed as a legal expert to the workshop on training needs.26 March and 23 June 2026, online · Horizon EuropeThe workshopThe recordingDTRIP4H
Interview Radio Radio InterviewLaw and the digital giantsThe Meta settlement on minors is not a conviction. The United States and Europe take opposite paths, and on AI agents the question of who answers remains open.Un Giorno Speciale on Radio Radio, with Alessio De Paolis · audio from 2:26:00 · in ItalianListen to the interviewWatch the videoRead the article
Digital Omnibus ContributionThe Digital Omnibus reshapes the AI ActNew deadlines for high-risk systems and a clarification on the AI literacy duty: more time to comply, no discount on preparing people and processes.Article written for the Skilla blog, in ItalianRead on Skilla
Digeat Festival 2026 SpeakerDigeat Festival 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo among the speakers of the festival on data protection, digital archives and the rules of the future. She takes part in the panel «The rules of AI: new laws or principles of law?».Friday 6 November 2026, 16:30, Ex Convitto Palmieri, LecceThe panelSpeaker profileThe festival
AI AnthropoCosmic 2026AI AnthropoCosmic 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo in the project of the Università Pontificia Salesiana on Person, Environment and Cosmos: moderator of the morning session of the closing conference and speaker at the AI Laboratori del Domani on e-commerce and AI.14 November 2026, online · 28 November 2026, Università Pontificia Salesiana, Rome · sessions held in ItalianThe conferenceThe sessionThe contributionThe scientific committeeSpeakerThe project