Cancello monumentale a un bivio che controlla l'accesso a un mercato digitale: metafora del gatekeeper e dell'esecuzione del Digital Markets Act

Immagine creata con IAAI-generated image

The Digital Markets Act put to the test by Google: €890 million for self-preferencing and steering

On 23 July 2026 the European Commission adopted two decisions finding that Google had failed to comply with the Digital Markets Act, and imposed fines totalling €890 million: €460 million for favouring its own services in search, and €430 million for restricting developers’ freedom to point users towards alternative offers on Google Play. The figure is striking, but the heart of the matter lies elsewhere, in the order to bring the conduct to an end and in the scrutiny the Commission will apply to Google’s adjustments. The Digital Markets Act, the regulation that promises fair and contestable digital markets, is showing how it means to be enforced.

Self-preferencing in search

The first decision concerns ranking. Article 6(5) of the Digital Markets Act forbids a gatekeeper from treating its own services more favourably, in ranking, than those of third parties, and requires transparent, fair and non-discriminatory conditions. The Commission found that Google instead gave preferential treatment to its own vertical services, from shopping to hotels, from transport to sports results, displaying them more prominently, at the top of the page or through enhanced visuals and filters, while comparable third-party services did not enjoy the same prominence. Hence the fine of €460 million.

Anti-steering on Google Play

The second decision concerns steering, that is the ability of app developers to tell customers about cheaper offers outside the store and to direct them to those channels. Article 5(4) of the regulation requires the gatekeeper to allow business users, free of charge, to communicate and promote their offers and to conclude contracts with customers through the channels they choose, including alternative app stores. The Commission found that Google prevented all of this. The company may receive a fee for facilitating the initial acquisition of a customer through Google Play, but the level of those fees and the length of the charging period went beyond what the regulation regards as compliant. That breach cost a further €430 million.

Beyond the fine: the order to stop and the compliance dialogue

The two decisions do not end with the fine. The Commission has ordered Google to bring the infringement to an end, treating third-party services in ranking fairly and without discrimination relative to its own, and allowing developers, both technically and contractually, to communicate with users, promote offers and conclude contracts outside Google Play as well. The company has sixty days to comply, failing which it faces periodic penalty payments of up to 5% of its average daily worldwide turnover under Article 31 of the regulation.

The Commission acknowledges that Google, after a period of dialogue, has proposed and begun testing changes to how it presents its own free services in search, such as shopping, hotels and flights, and regards them as substantial progress; changes to shopping ads and to content-related services such as sport are also under assessment, while the dialogue on how to apply the principles of the decision to AI Overviews and AI Mode remains open. On steering, the changes already rolled out are considered good progress. Google may still appeal the decisions before the EU courts.

One front of a wider enforcement effort

The case does not begin today. Google has been designated a gatekeeper since September 2023 for its search engine; on 25 March 2024 the Commission opened the investigations into self-preferencing and the steering rules, and on 19 March 2025 it informed the company of its preliminary finding of a breach, to which Google replied by exercising its rights of defence. The regulatory pressure had also shown itself a few days earlier: on 16 July 2026 the Commission issued Google binding specification measures on interoperability in Android and on the sharing of search data, again under the Digital Markets Act.

The method closely recalls the one already seen in the enforcement of the Digital Services Act, where a fine opens a phase of supervised remedy rather than closing the case. It is the same pattern by which the Union is operationalising its body of rules on the large platforms, protecting the contestability of markets and the freedom of choice of businesses and consumers, within a digital economy that European law wants to keep more open.

Two tracks now remain. On the first, Google must comply within sixty days and decide whether to accept the decisions or challenge them in court; on the second, the Commission will keep checking whether the proposed changes are enough to restore fair ranking and a genuine freedom to direct customers elsewhere. The two decisions show that the Digital Markets Act has distinct and complementary tools, the specification that prescribes how to open markets and the fine that punishes those who keep them closed, and that the Commission is willing to use both against the same gatekeeper.

Author: Valentina Grazia Sapuppo


AI AnthropoCosmic In evidenzaAI AnthropoCosmicUn progetto internazionale per un’IA a servizio dell’Uomo, dell’Ambiente e del Cosmo, che mette al centro la dignità della persona nella progettazione dei sistemi. Leggi l’articoloAI Open Mind AI AnthropoCosmic FeaturedAI AnthropoCosmicAn international project for an AI at the service of humanity, the environment and the cosmos, placing human dignity at the centre of system design. Read the articleAI Open Mind Agentic AI In evidenzaAgentic AILimiti prima dell’azione, evidenze durante, responsabilità dopo. Il volume di Nicola Fabiano sulla governance dei sistemi agentici, con la prefazione di Antonino Caffo.Capitolo 16 a cura dell’Avv. Valentina Grazia SapuppoLeggi l’articolo Agentic AI FeaturedAgentic AILimits before the action, evidence during, responsibility afterwards. Nicola Fabiano’s book on the governance of agentic systems, with a preface by Antonino Caffo.Chapter 16 by Valentina Grazia SapuppoRead the article
Testimonianza di Valentina Grazia Sapuppo per XUKRA, Meeting Standards 2026 TestimonianzaXUKRA” · Meeting StandardsValentina Grazia Sapuppo ha portato la sua testimonianza al workshop online di XUKRA” nell’ambito di Meeting Standards, l’iniziativa di Small Business Standards che avvicina le PMI europee alla normazione.30 giugno 2026, online · Meeting Standards, 4ª edizioneXUKRA”Meeting StandardsIniziativa europea di Small Business Standards - SBS
Locandina del workshop DTRIP4H Exploring User Needs, 26 marzo 2026PanelDTRIP4H · Gemelli digitali per la saluteValentina Grazia Sapuppo tra i main panellist del workshop «Exploring User Needs for DDTE: Ethics, Implementation, and the Future of Responsible Simulation» del progetto europeo DTRIP4H, con un intervento su governance, conformità e responsabilità. A giugno ha contribuito come esperto legale al workshop sui fabbisogni formativi.26 marzo e 23 giugno 2026, online · Horizon EuropeIl workshopLa registrazioneDTRIP4H
Intervista Radio Radio IntervistaLegge e colossi del digitaleIl patteggiamento di Meta sui minori non è una condanna. Stati Uniti ed Europa seguono strade opposte, e sugli agenti di IA resta aperta la domanda su chi risponde.Un Giorno Speciale su Radio Radio, con Alessio De Paolis · audio dal minuto 2:26:00Ascolta l’intervistaGuarda il videoLeggi l’articolo
Digital Omnibus ContributoIl Digital Omnibus cambia l’AI ActNuove scadenze per i sistemi ad alto rischio e un chiarimento sull’obbligo di AI literacy: più tempo per adeguarsi, nessuno sconto sulla preparazione di persone e processi.Articolo scritto per il blog di SkillaLeggi su Skilla
Digeat Festival 2026 SpeakerDigeat Festival 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo tra i relatori del festival dedicato a protezione dei dati, archivi digitali e regole del futuro. Interviene sul tema «Le regole dell’IA: nuove leggi o principi del diritto?».Venerdì 6 novembre 2026, ore 16:30, Ex Convitto Palmieri, LecceL’interventoLa scheda relatriceIl festival
AI AnthropoCosmic 2026AI AnthropoCosmic 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo nel progetto dell’Università Pontificia Salesiana su Persona, Ambiente e Cosmo: moderazione della sessione mattutina del Convegno finale e intervento negli AI Laboratori del Domani su commercio elettronico e IA.14 novembre 2026, online · 28 novembre 2026, Università Pontificia Salesiana, RomaIl convegnoL’incontroIl contributoIl comitato scientificoLa relatriceIl progetto
Testimony by Valentina Grazia Sapuppo for XUKRA, Meeting Standards 2026 TestimonyXUKRA” · Meeting StandardsValentina Grazia Sapuppo’s testimony for the XUKRA” online workshop, part of Meeting Standards, the Small Business Standards initiative bringing European SMEs closer to standardisation.30 June 2026, online · Meeting Standards, 4th editionXUKRA”Meeting StandardsEuropean initiative by Small Business Standards - SBS
Poster of the DTRIP4H workshop Exploring User Needs, 26 March 2026PanelDTRIP4H · Digital twins for healthValentina Grazia Sapuppo among the main panellists of the workshop “Exploring User Needs for DDTE: Ethics, Implementation, and the Future of Responsible Simulation” of the EU project DTRIP4H, speaking on governance, compliance and accountability. In June she contributed as a legal expert to the workshop on training needs.26 March and 23 June 2026, online · Horizon EuropeThe workshopThe recordingDTRIP4H
Interview Radio Radio InterviewLaw and the digital giantsThe Meta settlement on minors is not a conviction. The United States and Europe take opposite paths, and on AI agents the question of who answers remains open.Un Giorno Speciale on Radio Radio, with Alessio De Paolis · audio from 2:26:00 · in ItalianListen to the interviewWatch the videoRead the article
Digital Omnibus ContributionThe Digital Omnibus reshapes the AI ActNew deadlines for high-risk systems and a clarification on the AI literacy duty: more time to comply, no discount on preparing people and processes.Article written for the Skilla blog, in ItalianRead on Skilla
Digeat Festival 2026 SpeakerDigeat Festival 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo among the speakers of the festival on data protection, digital archives and the rules of the future. She takes part in the panel «The rules of AI: new laws or principles of law?».Friday 6 November 2026, 16:30, Ex Convitto Palmieri, LecceThe panelSpeaker profileThe festival
AI AnthropoCosmic 2026AI AnthropoCosmic 2026Valentina Grazia Sapuppo in the project of the Università Pontificia Salesiana on Person, Environment and Cosmos: moderator of the morning session of the closing conference and speaker at the AI Laboratori del Domani on e-commerce and AI.14 November 2026, online · 28 November 2026, Università Pontificia Salesiana, Rome · sessions held in ItalianThe conferenceThe sessionThe contributionThe scientific committeeSpeakerThe project